Discussions and Chat

[immy]

It is a counter previous trend but it's a signal. Lets see what happens 
 

[immy]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 

 

Hey, Isn't i a setup 1 on H1 time frame? wouldn't this mean it must be a signal on H4?
And if its a setup1 no H1, then it can't be a banana signal on H1. does it make sense to you? 

[immy]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 

 

What is this? Levels are 20 candles away? what does it mean? have you tested this idea and found that it gives you an edge? or is it just some thought that hit you and you made it part of your trade plan? why 20? why not 10 or 30? I 

The levels that we talk about are RIGHT there in front of you, you don't need to count bars. You took the trade RIGHT at the Levels... 

[Minsk]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 



 

Hi, hope it works... Not a setup for me. This is exactly the same as the USDCAD trade you took. Trading Range... cheers
 


 

It is a trading range, I agree with you. My thoughts when I placed the Limit Buy: that the candle right from the seed  broke the level upwards. So I thought, ok, this is confirmation. And a fresh cross of AO. So I can place a Limit Buy order on the seed.
Or should I have waited until a candle would have broken the top level much further to the left (at 130.241), before placing a Limit Buy order?

 
 

[Minsk]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 




 

Hey, Isn't i a setup 1 on H1 time frame? wouldn't this mean it must be a signal on H4?
And if its a setup1 no H1, then it can't be a banana signal on H1. does it make sense to you? 



 

what you say makes sense. It can't be both at the same time on the same timeframe. 
It was a Setup1 on the H1, although 4 candles before the seed on H1.
In theory I understand what you say. Then I look at both charts, and think, how? I see a Setup 1 like 4 candles before the Banana Seed on the H1. So not exactly at the same time, but more or less.
It does puzzle me now.
 
 
 

[Minsk]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 


 

What is this? Levels are 20 candles away? what does it mean? have you tested this idea and found that it gives you an edge? or is it just some thought that hit you and you made it part of your trade plan? why 20? why not 10 or 30? I 

The levels that we talk about are RIGHT there in front of you, you don't need to count bars. You took the trade RIGHT at the Levels... 

 

the 20 candle "rule" I didn't think up myself. It was somewhere in the discord that it was referred to as "when it's like 20 candles or more away, then it's not an issue". 
I might have interpreted this wrong and if that is the case, I will let go of counting, then the levels to the left in the screenshot are very valid. 
Should I then have waited until  price  first breaks the top level to the left, then place the Limit Buy and wait if it comes back to the seed?
 

[immy]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 



 

What is this? Levels are 20 candles away? what does it mean? have you tested this idea and found that it gives you an edge? or is it just some thought that hit you and you made it part of your trade plan? why 20? why not 10 or 30? I 

The levels that we talk about are RIGHT there in front of you, you don't need to count bars. You took the trade RIGHT at the Levels... 


 

the 20 candle "rule" I didn't think up myself. It was somewhere in the discord that it was referred to as "when it's like 20 candles or more away, then it's not an issue". 
I might have interpreted this wrong and if that is the case, I will let go of counting, then the levels to the left in the screenshot are very valid. 
Should I then have waited until  price  first breaks the top level to the left, then place the Limit Buy and wait if it comes back to the seed?
 

 

The Strategy that you need to follow has been laid out in the course. Those are the rules you need to follow. FOCUS on identifying the Banana Pattern. 2-3 Impulse Candles that BREAKOUT of a TRADING RANGE... not inside a Trading RAnge... does this make sense/ 

[Minsk]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 




 

What is this? Levels are 20 candles away? what does it mean? have you tested this idea and found that it gives you an edge? or is it just some thought that hit you and you made it part of your trade plan? why 20? why not 10 or 30? I 

The levels that we talk about are RIGHT there in front of you, you don't need to count bars. You took the trade RIGHT at the Levels... 



 

the 20 candle "rule" I didn't think up myself. It was somewhere in the discord that it was referred to as "when it's like 20 candles or more away, then it's not an issue". 
I might have interpreted this wrong and if that is the case, I will let go of counting, then the levels to the left in the screenshot are very valid. 
Should I then have waited until  price  first breaks the top level to the left, then place the Limit Buy and wait if it comes back to the seed?
 


 

The Strategy that you need to follow has been laid out in the course. Those are the rules you need to follow. FOCUS on identifying the Banana Pattern. 2-3 Impulse Candles that BREAKOUT of a TRADING RANGE... not inside a Trading RAnge... does this make sense/ 

 

yep
 

[immy]

I Placed a Limit Buy order on the Seed on USD-JPY.
Levels are more than 20 candles away, that's my count. Referring to to highest level in the screenshot.

 
 





 

Hey, Isn't i a setup 1 on H1 time frame? wouldn't this mean it must be a signal on H4?
And if its a setup1 no H1, then it can't be a banana signal on H1. does it make sense to you? 




 

what you say makes sense. It can't be both at the same time on the same timeframe. 
It was a Setup1 on the H1, although 4 candles before the seed on H1.
In theory I understand what you say. Then I look at both charts, and think, how? I see a Setup 1 like 4 candles before the Banana Seed on the H1. So not exactly at the same time, but more or less.
It does puzzle me now.
 
 
 

 

I can tell you this much... You don't yet understand the Fractal Geometry of Setup 1 and The BAnana Setup. IT will click one day. 
 

[immy]

It is a counter previous trend but it's a signal. Lets see what happens 
 

 

SL to BE lets see if it hits 3R... should not be an issue... I think even 5-7 R is possible. but I need a winner. I need that 3R...